by Terry MacCauley - Posted 17 minutes ago
When dealers pause marketing and training to save money, they often produce a larger, slower, more expensive recovery. Momentum is an economic asset. Treat it like one.
This is one argument, one image, and one playbook. The image is simple. A hen sits on an egg and waits for it to hatch. A plow horse arrives at first light, pulls the furrow, and earns the harvest year after year. Momentum in advertising, retargeting, and sales skills compounds. Pausing destroys momentum and creates a restart cost that often exceeds any short-term savings. The playbook that follows turns a dealership into a plow horse: disciplined sales practice, creative velocity, and a governance rule set that protects the asset.
A typical dealer that spends ten thousand dollars per month on advertising converts that spend into roughly forty thousand dollars in monthly gross profit. If that dealer pauses advertising for three months and then returns to market, a conservative estimate of the restart cost can exceed twenty thousand dollars for a single month of restored volume, while the dealer will have forgone roughly one hundred twenty thousand dollars in gross profit during the pause. When the pause, the restart cost, and the lost profit are combined, the strategic result is a large negative present value. In plain language, the money saved by waiting is small compared with the cost of returning to where the business already was.
Today we receive an explanation and a simple financial framework to test any pause, and a concrete governance and operating playbook that dealership leaders can put into practice this week.
The plow horse pulls. The hen sits on an egg and waits for it to hatch. The plow horse produces reliable output. The hen waits for a single event. That is the point, and everything in this article returns to that image. When leaders ask whether to pause, ask which animal they want running the dealership.
Momentum is an economic asset comprised of three measurable components.
Algorithmic momentum. Advertising platforms reward continuity. Accounts with steady creative and steady spend receive better delivery and lower cost per acquisition over time.
Audience momentum. Retargeting pools, brand recall, and repeat exposure are inventory items. They shrink when campaigns stop. Rebuilding them costs more than maintaining them.
Human momentum. Sales skills, response speed, and operational processes atrophy when unused. Retraining and ramp time are real costs.
These three elements interact. A pause reduces algorithmic delivery, shrinks audiences, and begins the slow loss of human capital. Restarting requires higher spend, heavier creative production, and time. That is the restart penalty.
Use the following notation.
S = monthly marketing SPEND.
L = monthly LEADS.
CPL = S divided by L, COST PER LEAD.
CR = CONVERSION RATE, expressed as a decimal.
Sales = L times CR.
GP = GROSS PROFIT per vehicle.
P = monthly gross profit attributable to marketing, that is, Sales times GP.
R = reactivation cost, incremental spend required to return to Sales target after a pause.
A direct estimate for R in a single month is:
R = (Sales_target / CR_post) * CPL_post − S
Where CR_post and CPL_post are conservative estimates of conversion and cost after the pause.
Assumptions (Actual numbers can be better or worse, but the math holds)
Monthly ad spend S = $10,000.
Baseline CPL = $50, so baseline leads L = 200.
Baseline CR = 5.0 percent.
Baseline sales per month = 10 vehicles.
GP = $4,000 per vehicle.
P = 10 × 4,000 = $40,000.
Monthly net gross profit after advertising P − S = $30,000.
Notes. Leads needed are rounded up to the nearest whole lead. Months to payback divided by R, the monthly net gross profit after advertising, which is $30,000 in this baseline. Replace the assumptions with dealership numbers for exact results.
A conservative net present value calculation clarifies the boardroom trade. Use a monthly discount rate of 8 percent annually, equal to about 0.6667 percent monthly. Calculate:
PV(lost gross profit) = present value of $40,000 for months one through three.
PV(savings) = present value of saved ad spend $10,000 for months one through three.
PV(reactivation R) = R discounted to the restart month (month four).
Interpretation
All three scenarios show a large negative NPV for a three-month pause. The dealer forfeits approximately $120,000 in gross profit over three months while saving only $30,000 in ad spend. Adding the reactivation spend produces a material loss in present value. The reactivation spend is significant and grows as CR_post falls and CPL_post rises.
Leaders should model NPV for any planned pause. If the NPV of the pause is negative beyond a tolerable threshold, the pause is a strategic error, not a saving.
Before approving any cut request require the following deliverables.
A modeled estimate of R under conservative assumptions for CPL_post and CR_post, including best, moderate, and worst cases.
The present value of the lost profit during the pause.
A simple comparison: if R plus PV(lost profit) minus PV(savings) is greater than zero, then the pause is a net economic loss and should not be approved without an alternative plan that preserves momentum.
If cuts are unavoidable for cash reasons, execute a prioritized cut plan that preserves a baseline and a rapid recovery path.
This rule turns feelings into a balance sheet decision.
The playbook has three pillars: 1) sales discipline, 2) creative velocity, and 3) advertising governance. Each pillar is a set of repeatable practices.
Two-minute morning huddle. Yesterday’s result, three priorities for the day, and assignments for follow-up. Keep it timed and public.
Ten-minute role play, daily. One rep practices objection handling for five minutes. One rep plays the customer. Coach provides one correction and one compliment. Rotate.
Activity scoreboard. Track calls, appointments set, show rate, and time to first response in minutes. Publish the scoreboard and use it to guide behavior.
Skill sprints. One hour per week devoted to a narrow skill, such as finance scripting or trade evaluation. Practice under pressure.
Outbound discipline. Carve time for proactive outreach even when the lot is busy. New customers come from consistent outbound efforts.
Sales activity must be deliberate. Being busy is not the same as being better.
Weekly creative lab. Pitch three micro-ideas, pick one to test, and document success criteria. Velocity matters.
Micro-tests. Two headlines, three video cut,s and short-run audiences produce learning faster than rare large bets.
Evergreen asset creation. Use slow periods to create financing explainers, customer stories, and virtual tours that scale when demand returns.
Local partnerships. Co-branded content with schools or charities increases relevance and recall.
Creative work must be scheduled, measured, and iterated.
Baseline policy. Do not reduce total retention and awareness spend below 10-30 percent of the prior month's spend. For most dealers, 20 percent is an efficient default unless competitive intensity or cash constraints demand a different number.
Reallocation rule. If CPL spikes in one channel, move a portion of spend to low-cost tests and retention, but do not zero out the channels that feed retargeting pools.
Retargeting guardrail. Maintain a small retargeting fleet that runs continuously to preserve pools of interested consumers.
Creative rotation. Refresh creative every two weeks to prevent ad fatigue.
Response time SLAs. Make minutes the metric for first contact. If the time to first response exceeds the threshold, escalate.
Reduce wasteful prospecting CPM bids and pause low-quality broad prospecting.
Pause expensive, low-probability experiments. Keep micro-tests.
Preserve baseline retention and awareness spend at 10 to 30 percent.
Do not cut training or retargeting. Those are the core of momentum.
If the emergency remains, reduce creative production cadence but keep at least a lean creative lab.
This hierarchy preserves the asset while acknowledging short-term cash stress.
Minute 0 to 0:30, Yesterday’s headline number: leads, sales, show rate.
Minute 0:30 to 1:00, Three priorities for today, named the owner for each.
Minute 1:00 to 1:30, One friction to remove.
Minute 1:30 to 2:00, Quick recognition of one small win.
Minute 0 to 1, Set scenario and stakes.
Minutes 1 to 5, Role-play a customer with a specific objection.
Minutes 5 to 7, Immediate coaching from the facilitator, one fix and one repeat.
Minutes 7 to 9, run the same scenario with another rep.
Minutes 9 to 10, Capture learning and apply to one prospect today.
Objective. Preserve retargeting audiences and brand frequency to reduce restart cost.
Minimum baseline. Maintain at least 20 percent of the prior month's spend allocated to retention and awareness. Adjust the baseline by market competition and cash constraints, but never below 10 percent.
Cut approval. Any proposed reduction below baseline requires a signed recovery analysis showing R, PV (lost profit), and the months to payback under worst-case assumptions. Cuts below baseline are approved only for documented cash emergencies.
Review. Weekly KPI review of CPL, CR, and retargeting audience size. Threshold breaches trigger immediate remediation.
Track these weekly and make them board-level.
Retargeting audience size and retention rate.
CPL by channel and trend.
Conversion rate by channel and by rep.
Time to first response, measured in minutes.
Monthly marketing spend as a percent of target revenue.
Reactivation cost R and the number of months to payback.
Creative velocity: number of micro-tests per week and win rate.
There are valid reasons to cut: legal exposure, fraud, insolvency, or platform suspensions. In those cases, preserve what is possible and rebuild governance as soon as feasible. Another exception is a deliberate strategic pivot that replaces mass digital with stronger, proven local channels. Even in those exceptions, protect retention and the sales discipline. The plow horse principle still applies: do not allow training and retention pools to evaporate.
Dealer X, lesson. Dealer X paused ad spend for 3 months to save $30,000, but forfeited roughly $120,000 in gross profit over the same period. In the worst-case restart scenario, the dealer incurred about $23,400 in reactivation spend and faced an estimated NPV hit of roughly $111,580. Retargeting pools had shrunk by 65 percent, CPL had doubled, and conversion rates had dropped about 40 percent. Recovery required months of extra spending and retraining and cost the dealer market share.
Dealer Y, playbook. Dealer Y reduced expensive prospecting by 40 percent while retaining 20 percent of the retention spend. The team used the slack to produce testimonials, train the sales floor and run micro-tests. When tax season arrived, Dealer Y scaled assets and converted at stronger rates with lower reacquisition cost.
These are archetypes. Most dealers sit between the two and can move toward the plow horse model with disciplined governance.
Culture is practice. Leaders must model the plow horse. That is visible discipline, not micromanagement. Join the morning huddle. Run the role play. Ask for the reactivation analysis before any cuts. Celebrate small practice wins and measure training as a budget line item. When a CFO asks for cuts, demand the financial model. When a sales manager asks to pause training because the month is busy, refuse. Trading training for busyness is the fastest route to worse outcomes.
A regional dealer reported, verbatim, "We paused to save payroll and ad spend. When I restarted, we spent twice what we saved, and my team had forgotten the scripts. The math did not lie. The pause was the worst single decision I made last year." Use that story to force the conversation into numbers.
Run a recovery model for one month of paused marketing using your real numbers. Use conservative CR_post and CPL_post assumptions and compute R, months to payback, and NPV.
Set a minimum baseline spend equal to 20 percent of last month’s ad budget focused on retention and awareness, or justify a different number in writing with a recovery plan.
Schedule daily 10-minute role-plays and a weekly creative lab. Measure and publish performance.
The hen sits on an egg and waits for it to hatch. The plow horse pulls the field day after day. The hen may eventually get what it waits for, but the plow horse builds a reliable, repeatable advantage on the balance sheet. Momentum is an asset. Protect it with governance, train for it daily, and build creative velocity to compound it.
At Big Time Advertising, we like to work with plow horses, dealers who plan for the horizon and do not waste time stressing about the now. We build dealership-specific recovery models, establish baseline policies that protect retargeting and training, and create the creative and sales routines that turn discipline into momentum. If you want numbers, not opinions, request a complimentary Dealership Scorecard valued at $4,500 to schedule a short walkthrough. We will show the decision rule, the recovery math and the first three actions to protect your momentum.
- by Terry MacCauley Founder & CEO
This week’s Big Time educational video is "AI Sales Strategy: Sell More in 2026" by The Humans In The Loop.
Forget blasting out cold DMs or scaling bad content. This video breaks down the 5 biggest AI mistakes sales teams are making—and how to avoid them. Learn how to sharpen your offer, fix your funnel, and use AI tools that actually convert.
