by Terry MacCauley - Posted 1 day ago
Walk into any dealer meeting today, and you will hear familiar frustrations: “Our Google budget is not paying off.” “Meta does not work anymore.” “The leads are not converting.” Dealers are quick to blame the platform. The truth is that the problem often is not where the ad is running. The problem is what the ad looks and feels like once it gets there.
Bad creative is quietly draining dealership budgets across the country. It is not always obvious, because the ads still go live, the clicks still appear in reports, and the invoices from the platforms continue to arrive on schedule. However, behind those numbers is a simple reality: if the creative is not capturing attention, the dollars behind it are not working.
Digital advertising is, at its core, a competition for attention. Every day, your ads compete against family photos, breaking news, memes, and content designed by some of the best creative teams in the world. A weak piece of creativity, such as a stock photo, a generic “Huge Sale” message, or a templated video, does not simply fail to win that competition. It never even has a chance.
What makes bad creative so damaging is the way it multiplies losses. It does not simply fail to attract a shopper. It actively makes every part of your advertising strategy more expensive.
Meta, Google, YouTube, and TikTok are all designed to reward ads that people interact with. An ad that earns clicks, comments, or views is considered relevant. Relevant ads are shown more often and charged lower rates. Advertisements that fail to earn engagement are penalized. They cost more per click, reach fewer people, and sink to the bottom of the priority list. Weak creative does not simply underperform. It increases the cost of every other dollar you spend.
That is why two dealers can spend the same ten thousand dollars and see dramatically different outcomes. Dealer A runs creative that feels sharp, authentic, and aligned with shoppers’ needs. Dealer B uses a stock image of a sedan with the words “Great Deals, Great Selection.” Dealer A ends the month with traffic that is two or three times the traffic. It is not because of luck. It is not because the algorithm favored them. It is because their creativity earned attention.
According to Meta, strong creatives can reduce cost per conversion by nearly 50 percent. Nielsen reports that creative quality accounts for almost 50 percent of an ad’s sales lift.
Weak creative is not only forgettable. It is expensive.
Automotive advertising has leaned on the exact formulas for decades: huge selection, low payments, credit for everyone, and bold fonts over stock photos. These approaches filled television spots and newspapers in the past, and at the time, they worked well enough. But digital platforms have changed the environment.
A social media feed is not a newspaper. A pre-roll video on YouTube is not a television spot. Shoppers are not waiting patiently for your message. They are scrolling and swiping. You may only have two or three seconds to win their attention, and you will be forgotten if you fail.
Most dealer creatives fail here. It looks generic, tells no story, and gives no reason to pause. And in a marketplace where attention is currency, this kind of creative begins at zero.
Creative is not only about earning a click. It is about shaping how your dealership is perceived.
Shoppers make immediate judgments based on what they see. If your creative looks cheap, dated, or inconsistent, they assume the same about your store. If your ads look like placeholders rather than polished branding, shoppers hesitate. They wonder: Will this store take care of me? Will they stand behind the car they sell me?
When your creativity is strong and consistent, the opposite happens. It communicates stability. It signals that your dealership is professional, trustworthy, and established. People want to buy from a brand that looks organized and reliable. People want to buy from a strong-looking brand. Weak creative makes you look small before you ever shake a customer’s hand.
This does not mean abandoning the personal touch. A dealership can be family-owned, approachable, and community-driven while still presenting a professional and modern image. The key is authenticity combined with polish. Your creative is where that balance becomes visible.
Good creative does not always require a large budget or high-end production. It requires intention and authenticity.
It showcases real people: your sales team, your customers, and your vehicles. It communicates real offers that matter to shoppers: approvals, payment flexibility, and same-day drive-offs. It feels like your dealership, not like a template that could belong to anyone.
However, there is also a difference between what an amateur creates and what a professional creates. Professionals know the fundamentals that make creative work. They understand color theory, choosing shades that pop on digital feeds without clashing. They understand typography, selecting fonts that resonate with customers and carry the right tone. They understand space awareness, ensuring that every ad has breathing room, balance, and hierarchy so the eye goes exactly where it should. These fundamentals are invisible when done correctly, but painfully obvious when they are ignored.
The strongest creativity often comes from straightforward, authentic content executed with professional discipline. A short video of a customer ringing a bell or driving away can outperform an expensive studio production because it feels genuine. A seasonal campaign that connects with community experiences, such as back-to-school or tax season, resonates more deeply than a recycled “Big Sale” graphic.
Above all, a strong creative is consistent. It carries your voice, visuals, and message across every channel. Over time, customers recognize and expect your ads, which builds familiarity and trust.
Ads with strong creative achieve two to three times higher click-through rates than generic dealer ads.
Creative determines whether all of your other investments succeed or fail.
When your creative is strong, your paid search ads perform better because shoppers already recognize your name. Seasonal promotions gain traction because the message feels urgent and memorable. Even your CRM follow-ups become more effective because customers recall the ad that initially drew their attention.
When creative is weak, efficiency collapses. Your dollars work harder and deliver less. Campaigns fall flat. Your CRM fills with leads who barely remember why they clicked in the first place. Adding more budget does not solve the problem. Creative is the ignition key. Without it, the engine will not start, no matter how much fuel you add.
It is easy to blame the platform. Google is too expensive. Meta is past its prime. TikTok does not drive real buyers. The reality is that the issue is often not the channel. The issue is the creative.
The encouraging news is that creativity is within your control. Fixing it does not require doubling your spend. It requires rethinking your approach.
Ask yourself: Would I stop scrolling for this? Would I feel curious enough to click? Does this ad feel like my dealership? Does it reflect a brand I would trust?
If you cannot answer yes, neither will your customers.
The dealers who will win are not necessarily the ones with the largest budgets. They are the ones who treat creative as the linchpin of their advertising.
The conclusion is simple. Stop wasting money on ads that are not worth watching. Stop treating creative as an afterthought. Start treating it as the center of your marketing strategy.
Digital advertising is fiercely competitive but can also be highly rewarding for dealers who get it right. Strong creative earns attention, lowers costs, and builds long-term momentum. Weak creative ensures that no platform in the world can deliver success.
Build your dealership's reputation on producing creative that does more than run. It wins. Advertisements should be designed to capture attention, lower costs, and turn shoppers into buyers. Dealers who invest in creative are not simply buying campaigns. They are building trust, credibility, and long-term profitability.
Bad creative is a cost. Good creative is an investment. Strong creativity combined with strong branding is what separates dealerships that get scrolled past from dealerships that customers choose to buy from. Bad creative is expensive. Good creative is an investment. Strong creativity combined with strong branding is what brings customers through your doors.
-by Terry MacCauley, Founder & CEO
This week’s Big Time Advertising motivational video is "NO EXCUSES" by Ben Lionel Scott. It’s not about motivation—it’s about accountability.
If you’re waiting for the right time, the perfect plan, or someone else to push you—stop. The only thing between you and progress is the excuse you keep telling yourself.
Dealers deserve vehicle feeds that work as hard as they do. Get Best Used Cars delivers inventory to Google, Meta, TikTok, Microsoft, and more. All organized, sorted, clean, and guaranteed to be live in under 48 hours.
